Register FAQ Upgrade Membership Community Calendar Today's Posts Search
Go Back   Vulcan Bagger Forums > Technical :: Maintenance :: Performance > 1500 & 1600 Nomad

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 12-06-2011, 02:11 AM   #16
Monkeyman   Monkeyman is offline
Top Contributor
 
Monkeyman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: North Wilkesboro, NC
Posts: 6,289
You know, $30 and a phone call will get you some coasters (reed valve eliminator plates) from Chuckster. I just got mine and will install them some time this winter. If nothing else, that would eliminate the reed valves as a problem.
__________________
Christopher "Monkeyman" Gray
----------------------------
Widows Sons "Overseers"
Patriot Guard Rider
USArmy 1987-1990
2021 Can Am Spyder RT

2018 Can Am Spyder RT Limited - SOLD
2014 Nomad - SOLD
2012 Victory Vision - SOLD
2007 Black Nomad - SOLD
VMC #9367
VBA #1860



Login or Register to Remove Ads
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 06:28 AM   #17
chuckster131   chuckster131 is offline
Sr. Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Jackson, Michigan
Posts: 1,367
Interesting Tom,
I do notice that the throttle body is louder with the open intake verses the stock and maybe that is what you are hearing on acceleration. Can't think of anything else that would give off the noise, as long as you have the plug in the reed valve hose it is like having the coasters installed.
Keep us posted
__________________
Joe (Chuckster) Norris
Jackson, Michigan
2007 Goldwing
2010 Voyager (Blue/Silver)sold
2001 Nomad (gone, but not forgotten)

www.chucksterscustoms.com
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 05:57 PM   #18
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Next clue in the puzzle . . .

I just did a compression test. Spec is 50 - 85 PSI. Rear cylinder checks in at 80. Started at about 50 and climbed up to 80 from there. Front cylinder reads 160 PSI. First stroke read 90 and it climbed up to 160 over the next 3 or 4 strokes. Did the check twice just to make sure I wasn't seeing things.

Also, the right plug on the front cylinder is pretty carboned up. The left plug looks reasonable. Both rear plugs look reasonable.

The manual says high compression is caused by:
1) Carbon buildup possibly due to damaged valve stem, valve guide, stem oil seal and/or damaged piston oil rings. May be white exhaust smoke.
2) Incorrect cylinder head gasket thickness.
3) Damaged or missing compression release cam spring.
4) Compression release weights do not move smoothly.

2 is out. So that leaves 1, 3 or 4, unless someone knows of other causes. Wondering now if this problem has absolutely nothing to do with the intake and cam chain extenders. Just really bad timing.

Time for some research on high compression.

Unless someone can suggest something else to check, it looks like I'll be starting to take apart the front cylinder head in the near future. Has anyone else done that? Would appreciate any insights into the process, like do I really have to remove the engine, or is there enough room to get the top end off with the engine in the frame.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 06:13 PM   #19
trosco   trosco is offline
Sr. Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 1,464
I'd say that you broke the front cylinder tensioner when trying to force the install. So the front cylinder tensioner puts no tension on the cam chain. Now when you start the motor and while it is runing the noise is that cam chain whacking the spark plug housing and the reason you have no power is the cam timing is off on that front cylinder. The puffs of outbound air at the throttle body is your intake valve still being open when the compression stroke starts. If you haven't already bent a valve keep running the motor and things will get far enough out of time that you'll snap a valve or punch a hole in that front piston. Don't know where you got your compression specs but 50-85 psi is not right for a healthy cylinder either,
__________________
trosco: just call me Ross
2007 Black & Titanium Nomad
(Nomad made 65K but got replaced 2014)
2010 Titanium Goldwing
2014 KLR 650 New Edition
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 06:48 PM   #20
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Quote:
Originally Posted by trosco View Post
I'd say that you broke the front cylinder tensioner when trying to force the install. So the front cylinder tensioner puts no tension on the cam chain. Now when you start the motor and while it is runing the noise is that cam chain whacking the spark plug housing and the reason you have no power is the cam timing is off on that front cylinder. The puffs of outbound air at the throttle body is your intake valve still being open when the compression stroke starts. If you haven't already bent a valve keep running the motor and things will get far enough out of time that you'll snap a valve or punch a hole in that front piston. Don't know where you got your compression specs but 50-85 psi is not right for a healthy cylinder either,
What you say makes a lot of sense, except for one thing. I just pulled the front tensioner and it looks fine. Both springs are intact, and the rod is extended just above the body of the tensioner. Before I added the extenders, it was about 3/16 recessed (5 clicks left). So with the extenders, that would be about right. But everything else adds up.

What is odd though is I stuck a finger in the tensioner opening and can feel the cam chain guide. It is recessed the same distance as the extender, and doesn't seem to have any give to it when I push gently on it. But it seems to be bent right where the tensioner hits it, and it seems to end right above that with a sharp edge. The picture in the manual shows it being a smooth curve and extending quite a bit above the tensioner with a rounded end. I think I have a snapped cam chain guide although I can't figure out how that would have happened. And I know the tensioner was fully recessed when I installed it.

I'll pull the spark plug tube to see if there are any marks on it, as soon as I can locate a 27 mm hex wrench. There shouldn't be any given that I added the extenders before I ran out travel, but I bet I'll find some.

Also, the compression spec is on page 5-32 of the service manual, although I agree that it is a low spec. I would normally think 120 or so.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA



Login or Register to Remove Ads
Last edited by tomm; 12-06-2011 at 06:50 PM.
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 07:27 PM   #21
ponch   ponch is offline
Sr. Contributor
 
ponch's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Way East Valley
Posts: 12,014
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomm View Post
What you say makes a lot of sense, except for one thing. I just pulled the front tensioner and it looks fine. Both springs are intact, and the rod is extended just above the body of the tensioner. Before I added the extenders, it was about 3/16 recessed (5 clicks left). So with the extenders, that would be about right. But everything else adds up.

What is odd though is I stuck a finger in the tensioner opening and can feel the cam chain guide. It is recessed the same distance as the extender, and doesn't seem to have any give to it when I push gently on it. But it seems to be bent right where the tensioner hits it, and it seems to end right above that with a sharp edge. The picture in the manual shows it being a smooth curve and extending quite a bit above the tensioner with a rounded end. I think I have a snapped cam chain guide although I can't figure out how that would have happened. And I know the tensioner was fully recessed when I installed it.

I'll pull the spark plug tube to see if there are any marks on it, as soon as I can locate a 27 mm hex wrench. There shouldn't be any given that I added the extenders before I ran out travel, but I bet I'll find some.

Also, the compression spec is on page 5-32 of the service manual, although I agree that it is a low spec. I would normally think 120 or so.
Why don't you have Mac look at it? You two live in the same state and I am sure he wouldn't mind.

On the other hand, may be someone put a potato in one of the tail pipes.
__________________
Ponch
VBA 0019
VROC 8109-R
BMWMOA 162849
BMWRA 41335

BMW: When you care enough to ride the very best.

My Motorrad Blog
My Motorrad YouTube


2009 BMW R1200RT

Previous bikes:2007 Nomad | 2001 Vulcan 800 Classic | 1984 GPz750 | 1978 KZ1000A2

Rallies: Custer '09|Prairie Du Chien '10|Crescent City '11

Last edited by ponch; 12-06-2011 at 07:32 PM.
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 07:51 PM   #22
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Quote:
Originally Posted by ponch View Post
Why don't you have Mac look at it? You two live in the same state and I am sure he wouldn't mind.

On the other hand, may be someone put a potato in one of the tail pipes.
Good idea. I just sent him a PM, although I understand he hasn't been around much lately. Hopefully, he'll check in and be open to helping me.

And negative on the potato. That would be Maine, not New Hampster. And I already checked the exhaust for one of those little critters.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-06-2011, 07:58 PM   #23
ponch   ponch is offline
Sr. Contributor
 
ponch's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Way East Valley
Posts: 12,014
Quote:
Originally Posted by tomm View Post
Good idea. I just sent him a PM, although I understand he hasn't been around much lately. Hopefully, he'll check in and be open to helping me.

And negative on the potato. That would be Maine, not New Hampster. And I already checked the exhaust for one of those little critters.
I am sure you read the manual, but there is a caution when working on the camchain extenders:

Quote:
This is a non-return type cam chain tensioner. The push rod does not return to its original position once it moves out to take up camshaft chain slack. Observe all the rules listed below:
When removing the tensioner, do not take out the mounting bolts only halfway. Retightening the mounting bolts from this position could damage the tensioner and the camshaft chain. Once the bolts are loosened, the tensioner must be removed and reset as described in “Camshaft Chain Ten- sioner Installation”.
Do not turn over the crankshaft while the tensioner is removed. This could upset the cam chain timing, and damage the valves.
I'll PM you.
__________________
Ponch
VBA 0019
VROC 8109-R
BMWMOA 162849
BMWRA 41335

BMW: When you care enough to ride the very best.

My Motorrad Blog
My Motorrad YouTube


2009 BMW R1200RT

Previous bikes:2007 Nomad | 2001 Vulcan 800 Classic | 1984 GPz750 | 1978 KZ1000A2

Rallies: Custer '09|Prairie Du Chien '10|Crescent City '11
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07-2011, 09:27 AM   #24
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Quote:
Originally Posted by ponch View Post
I am sure you read the manual, but there is a caution when working on the camchain extenders:
Yup, read that caution multiple times. Followed the directions to the letter.

Going to go out and buy one of those lighted telescoping mirrors today to see if I can look around inside, but I'm pretty sure I know what I'll find based on feeling around in there.

Only thing I can think of is the guide is supposed to be hinged on the bottom and free on the top, and somehow, the top got pulled away from the chain and then got stuck on something. When I pushed in on the tensioner to install it, the guide didn't pivot against the chain like it should have but instead creased in the middle, either immediately or as soon as I started the engine. The rest is history.

I have no explanation for how or why this would have happened because like I said, I read the instructions multiple times and followed them exactly.

But figures. Hundreds of folks have probably done this mod before me without problems. Doesn't sound like anyone has ever experienced this.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07-2011, 10:48 AM   #25
ringadingh   ringadingh is offline
 
ringadingh's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Newmarket Ontario Canada
Posts: 35,387
Id take a look at your #3 & #4 causes for high compression, before you start tearing into the motor too deep.
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07-2011, 02:21 PM   #26
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Quote:
Originally Posted by ringadingh View Post
Id take a look at your #3 & #4 causes for high compression, before you start tearing into the motor too deep.
I agree. Got all winter to sort this out. At least I have something definitive to work with now, meaning the high compression. And that I have to start looking into that top end on the front jug.

Everything else is just a guess.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-07-2011, 02:36 PM   #27
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Quote:
Originally Posted by trosco View Post
I'd say that you broke the front cylinder tensioner when trying to force the install. So the front cylinder tensioner puts no tension on the cam chain. Now when you start the motor and while it is runing the noise is that cam chain whacking the spark plug housing and the reason you have no power is the cam timing is off on that front cylinder. The puffs of outbound air at the throttle body is your intake valve still being open when the compression stroke starts. If you haven't already bent a valve keep running the motor and things will get far enough out of time that you'll snap a valve or punch a hole in that front piston. Don't know where you got your compression specs but 50-85 psi is not right for a healthy cylinder either,
Think I understand why the compression spec is so low. It's that KACR compression release. Manual says it reduces compression when the bike is starting and raises it back to normal when the bike is running. Since the bike isn't running during the test, the compression on a normal cylinder would be low.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-11-2011, 02:25 PM   #28
tomm   tomm is offline
 
tomm's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Lee, New Hampshire
Posts: 568
Update - Spoke with Mac about the problem. He thinks the cam chain slipped. Engine probably stopped with one lobe on the cam right at the top, and when I removed the tensioner, the cam rotated off the lobe under pressure from the valve spring and slipped the chain. It all seems to add up.

I also pulled the spark plug tube, and with a mirror and a bright light, I can see the bottom of the camshaft gear, enough to see the timing marks. Also pulled the alternator outer cover so I could rotate the crankshaft by hand. By counting teeth on the camshaft gear (there are 45), I could roughly approximate where the timing should be (I think within a tooth). Looks to be about 8 teeth off. That also seems consistent with the camshaft rotating off a lobe. Probably wouldn't have slipped just one tooth.

Anyway, Mac said he would be willing to do the repair for me. I've done a lot of bike work, but think this might be just a little over my head.

Although this sequence of events must be really unusual as I can't find any other reference to it anywhere on the web, It obviously can happen. I think if I were to do cam chain extenders again, I would pull the spark plug tubes and the alternator outer cover before I removed the tensioners, and rotate the crankshaft by hand until the crankshaft timing marks were lined up, the pistons were at TDC on compression, the valves were fully closed, and I could check the tension on the cam chain with my finger through the spark plug tube opening. That way, there would be absolutely no chance of this happening. Oh well. Like Thomas Edison once said. I've never failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that don't work.
__________________


Tom Maziarz (tomm)
VBA #00766
2008 Kawasaki Nomad (Black)
1978 Suzuki GS750EC (My son is riding it now.)

2017: National Rally - Lake George, NY
2016: NE US / E Canada Rally - Mont Tremblant, QC
2015: National Rally - Eureka Springs, AR
2014: NE US / E Canada Rally - Lincoln, NH
2012: NE US / E Canada Rally - Wellsboro, PA
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-11-2011, 02:50 PM   #29
Netnorske   Netnorske is offline
Top Contributor
 
Netnorske's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Everett, Washington
Posts: 5,709
This sounds like a nightmare scenario for sure. With Mac on the case, I'm sure you will be on the road to recovery in short order. Sounds like you know your way around a bike motor though. Good luck with the repairs.
__________________
Kris Olsen
VBA #0691
2017 HD Ultra Limited Low
2013 Victory Cross Country Tour
2012 1700 Vulcan Voyager
2008 1600 Vulcan Nomad
1997 Vulcan 800 Classic

"Growing old is mandatory, but growing up is optional"



Custer 2009|Kalispell 2010|Cortez 2010|Crescent City 2011|Kanab 2012|Canmore 2012|Estes Park 2013|Orofino 2014|Lake Tahoe 2015|Red Lodge 2016
 
Reply With Quote
Old 12-12-2011, 05:42 AM   #30
Cajunrider   Cajunrider is offline
 
Cajunrider's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: (SE Louisiana)
Posts: 8,340
Tom if there is such a thing as luck, yours sure wasn't very good with this project. This is the first case I've heard of this happening. Hope all works out for you.
__________________


2016 Electra Glide Ultra Limited CVO
Palladium Silver / Phantom Blue
110 cu in SE

2012 Electra Glide Ultra Limited (Traded 6/22/16)
Tequila Sunrise / HD Orange
Vance & Hines true dual headers
Rinehart 4" slip ons
Screamin Eagle Super Tuner
Screamin Eagle Stage 1 intake
Dyno tuned
H.O.G.# 4514015

2007 Nomad 1600 (Traded 6/23/12)
VBA #482
 
Reply With Quote
Reply





Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.